There’s no doubt about it, ‘Aap Jaisa Koi’ has its heart in the right place. It talks about love, age, sexuality, consent, and patriarchal hypocrisy with a tenderness that’s rare in Hindi cinema today. However, here’s the thing: despite its honest intent, the film stumbles because it refuses to be bolder. It tries to be everything, sweet, safe, relevant, romantic and thus ends up not being enough of any.
Director Vivek Soni sets up a premise that promises depth: a 42-year-old virgin Sanskrit teacher from Jamshedpur, Shrirenu Tripathi (R. Madhavan), finds love in the unlikeliest of places, with a younger, confident French teacher, Madhu Bose (Fatima Sana Shaikh) from Kolkata. But instead of diving into the raw complexities this story could explore, the film wraps itself in candyfloss and nostalgia, too afraid to get uncomfortable.
Madhavan is predictably solid in Aap Jaisa Koi. Fatima is a revelation; she plays Madhu with charm and controlled fire. Together, their chemistry feels lived-in and sincere. But the real tragedy? They’re both let down by a hesitant script that’s too busy keeping things palatable for the family crowd.
The direction plays it safe. The cinematography is lovely, the background score doesn’t intrude, and the tone is gentle. It’s all so soft, it almost feels like the film is whispering when it should at least be speaking up clearly.
The first half teases you. You think this is going to be a bold take on ageism, sexuality, and the unfair burden society places on both men and women. But before you know it, the film abandons its edge. It crawls back into Dharma’s comfort zone with watered-down family drama, token liberalism, and forced subplots that derail the narrative.
By the time we hit the second half, the storytelling loses its nerve completely. New characters pop in, conflicts get diluted, and the moral messaging becomes more about checking boxes than pushing boundaries. The film doesn’t challenge patriarchy; it politely knocks on its door and then tiptoes away.
The scene that could have defined ‘Aap Jaisa Koi’ is when Madhu tells Shrirenu, “Tum kyun decide karoge meri limit?”. It is powerful, but fleeting. It’s the kind of confrontation the entire movie should’ve been built around. Instead, it gets buried under scenes of moral policing and family melodrama. That’s not just disappointing. It’s a letdown for a story that wanted to matter.
Supporting actors like Ayesha Raza and Namit Das are completely underused. The subplots — about sexless marriages, ambition-crushing parenting, and the judgment women face are introduced with promise but go nowhere meaningful. It’s like the film keeps throwing ideas in the air but forgets to catch any of them.
Let me say it loud and clear: Aap Jaisa Koi is not a bad film. It’s sincere, well-acted, and wants to say something important. However, it ends up saying it in low, hushed tones. It seems too scared to offend, too careful to be cinematic truth.
Aap Jaisa Koi could’ve been a bold, unapologetic take on love, desire, and autonomy in modern India. Instead, it’s a delicate dance of good intentions and missed opportunities.
Yes, still watch it, especially if you miss the softness of old-school romance and want a break from formulaic thrillers. But go in knowing that this film had the chance to roar, and it chose to whisper.
For a movie that starts with so much promise, this one deserved to be far more courageous.
BLOG/051/615/1110/ To connect, send an email . Twitter S_kotnala
