India has discovered a new human right. Not water. Not clean air and No pothole-free roads.
The Right to Disconnect.
A private member’s bill has been floated in Parliament that would allow employees to ignore office calls, emails, and pings after work hours. Switch off. Log out. Live your life. Eat dinner while it’s still warm. Sleep without dreaming of unread emails.
It sounds lovely. It also sounds like unicorn farming.
The intent is noble. The timing is earnest. The optimism is… cinematic.
Because in the real Indian workplace, disconnecting is not a legal problem. It is a cultural fantasy.
The Five-Day Workweek That Never Existed
Let’s first address the great lie we all grew up believing: the five-day workweek.
It exists on offer letters, HR decks, and inspirational posters near the coffee machine. In practice, it quietly becomes a six-day, sometimes seven-day emotional commitment.
Weekends, in particular, are not days off. They are buffer zones. Leaving at five is still half-day.
That awkward space where you’re not working, but you’re also not not working.
Saturday morning begins with optimism. Saturday evening ends with, “Let me just check once.”
Sunday night is spent reconnecting the chaotic dots of business dynamics you courageously ignored for 36 hours.
Young professionals don’t disconnect on weekends. They hold their breath.
Law vs Life: A Short Circuit Waiting to Happen
The proposed Right to Disconnect Bill allows employees to ignore office communication outside work hours.
On paper, this sounds empowering. In today’s unstable, high-competition job market, it may function more like unplugging a live wire with wet hands.
Disconnecting without cultural change will not create balance; it will only create anxiety.
Because the unspoken fear remains: If I don’t reply, someone else will.
And in a country where “NO” is often considered a rude suggestion rather than a complete sentence, silence can look suspiciously like disengagement.
This is not Europe. This is a land where responsiveness is mistaken for commitment and exhaustion is worn like a badge of honour.
The Managerial Class and the Cult of Face Time
Let’s be honest. The managerial class still operates on face time, not output.
The boss may not know what you delivered, but they know you were “available”. Bonuses are rare. Praise is conditional. Availability is mandatory.
And then, of course, there is the ghost in every productivity debate: Narayan Murthy’s comment about working longer hours. Many laughed. Many protested. And most of them quietly went back to working those hours, because ideals don’t pay EMIs.
India doesn’t reward efficiency. It rewards endurance more.
My Own Fictional Work-Life Balance
I remember achieving something resembling work-life balance only much later in my professional life. Not because the system changed, but because my role and my expectations of myself did.
When I decided how my team worked, balance became negotiable.
When I became a consultant, balance became… a well-written lie.
Working on your “own schedule” is often code for working all schedules.
The schedule that you want to stick to. The schedule your client and your boss want. And God forbid if you work two time zones, as the problem magnifies.
Entrepreneurship and consulting are not escape routes. They are premium subscriptions to being always on.
The Global Examples (Yes, We have heard of Them)
Yes, countries like France, Belgium, Ireland, and Australia have all legislated some form of ‘Right to Disconnect’- the right to refuse after-hours contact.
And I heard that it mostly works there. Because it sits on foundations we haven’t fully built yet, Trust, Clear role definitions, Strong unions or enforcement and cultures where leaving on time is not a moral failure
Importing the law without importing the mindset is like installing seatbelts in a car with no brakes.
The Question Nobody Is Asking
A gentle, satirical question: Will the Honourable Member of Parliament who proposed this bill be able to follow it herself?
Politics is a 24×7 profession. Governance doesn’t log out at 6 pm. Crises don’t wait for Monday.
If even lawmakers can’t disconnect from their jobs, can legislation alone protect employees whose performance reviews are written by someone who replies at midnight?
The Real Missing Piece: Self-Accountability
The truth is uncomfortable: no law can replace self-accountability.
The Right to Disconnect only works in mature organisations where: Energy, intent and engagement are measured, not just hours. People feel safe calling out boundary violations and the managers are trained to plan better, not panic faster.
Such environments in India are still exceptions, not the rule.
Ironically, the only people who truly disconnect are business owners, who are actually never disconnected at all.
What Might Actually Work
Instead of pretending we can switch off work like a light, maybe we need smarter pressure points:
- Mandatory double pay for extra hours. Watch how quickly “urgent” work, as defined by the management, becomes “Monday morning”.
- Counting travel time as work hours. Overnight business trips suddenly look less romantic and more accountable.
- Senior approval for weekend work. This worked in agencies in the 1990s. Miraculously, work got planned better.
When inconvenience hits the balance sheet, discipline follows.
NET NET- The Hard Truth
The Right to Disconnect is a beautiful idea trapped in an immature ecosystem.
Until we fix planning, accountability, trust, and leadership insecurity, ignoring office calls after hours won’t feel like freedom. It will feel like gambling.
The bill may never become law. And perhaps that’s fine because what India really needs is not the right to disconnect but the right to work without fear, and the courage to redesign how work actually gets done.
Until then, please excuse me.
It’s Sunday evening, and I need to check a few emails.
BLOG/096/637/1154 To connect, send an email . Twitter S_kotnala
The Infinite Game Mindsset stop treating life as a finite game
